Monday, July 09, 2007

An Excellent Analogy

I discovered that our family doctor doesn’t have a license and never attended an accredited medical school.

For generations, my family has been attending the same clinic and seeing the same doctor. He is usually a really nice guy. In his office, he has his medical school certificate hanging on his wall. It says he is a doctor.

Over the last few years, I have had my doubts though. Most of his medical advice doesn’t work and seems very non-medical in nature. So, I decided to check out his background. With just a little research, I determined that he never attended medical school at all. In fact, he never graduated from college. The state board has never issued him a license.


When I found this out, I called him. He had his staff escort me from his clinic. I called all my family and told them what I had found. When I did, my parents hung up the phone and refused to discuss it. Later, my mother told me I was lying and they needed to rely on the doctor’s advice because he has been treating my father’s heart condition for years. My siblings did the same. My sister’s son is interning with the doctor and the doctor has assured him that he is accredited.


When I offered to fax them the information and records I had discovered, they all refused. One sibling asked me how I even knew the educational records I examined hadn’t been altered by the good doctor’s known adversaries.


So I stopped going to the doctor, but my parents, siblings, aunts and uncles all continue to go and won’t hear any criticism of their doctor or his background. So when we get together, discussion of the doctor is taboo, but I role my eyes every time I have to listen to stories about their frequent trips to the doctor and his sage advice and I see how ill they all appear.

******Question********

Would YOU want to know if your doctor isn’t who he claims to be?

It certainly doesn't hurt to be Skeptical

5 comments:

MOTHER OF MANY said...

My daughter insists your post is purely allegorical,I get the point if it is.

Astarte Moonsilver said...

Oh, it is, Allyson. But, very fitting for explaining the blindness of Mormonism. I have often said to my family that believing something to be true in the face of all the evidence that proves it false is delusion, not faith. Faith is for things that cannot be explained or proven, and Mormonism has been proven overwhelmingly false many times over by real scholars and real research, not just apologists and church jockeys trying to maintain the base.

Thanks for your comment, and for stopping by! I haven't been around much lately because I just moved to a new home and finally got my internet running after doing without for about two weeks. I was hoping that I wouldn't be dropped! :>)

Astarte Moonsilver said...

I meant to say that it IS a made up story, not factual. I don't want to alarm anyone out there!

I borrowed this post from a regular at postmormon.com His name is Skeptical, that's why I linked the word.

Anonymous said...

A good analogy. Especially in contrast with the "if a dam was breaking, wouldn;t you want to tell everyone?" analogy that Mormons use to explain why missionary work is so important.

If you discover the most important thing in the world, it's your responsibility to tell everyone. If you subsequently discover it's a sham, you should forget it, keep your mouth shut, and try to convince yourself otherwise.

:(

Sister Mary Lisa said...

I swear I wrote a doctor analogy once...wonder if it was on an Otterson thread or what. I can't find it.

Great stuff you wrote here.